How to Check Whether a Research Paper Supports Your Claim

A DOI tells you which paper you have. A worked example on retrieval practice shows how to decide what that paper lets you write.

LinkedIn X
Illustration of a study report under a magnifier

Start with the sentence you want to cite

Write the exact sentence you plan to publish, then underline every part that would need evidence. Take “Quizzes always improve learning more than rereading.” The word always commits you to every setting and time point. “Learning” could mean recall, understanding, or performance on an unfamiliar task. Before adding a citation, say which of those outcomes you actually mean.

Read the study with four questions in mind: Who took part? What did they do? What was the comparison? What did the researchers measure, and when?

Read the same paper at two time points

In a 2006 study, Henry L. Roediger III and Jeffrey D. Karpicke compared restudying prose passages with taking recall tests on them. In Experiment 1, students took a final memory test after five minutes, two days, or one week. The direction of the result depended on the delay: restudying did better after five minutes, and initial testing did better after the longer delays. See the study abstract and Figure 1 in the paper.

Draft wordingWhat to check in the paper
“Quizzes”Students tried recalling prose passages. Check the test and whether feedback was provided before applying the result to a different quiz format.
“Improve learning”The outcome was recall of passage content. The experiment does not establish gains in transfer, course grades, or comprehension measured another way.
“Always”The five-minute result favored restudying. The delayed results favored initial testing.

One defensible revision: “In a study using prose passages, students who initially practiced recall remembered more after two days or one week than students who restudied the passages.”

Find the passage, result, or figure you can point to

Start with the abstract for orientation. In the methods, identify the comparison, the sample, and the timing. In the results, find the exact table or figure that reports the outcome you are citing. Read the caption and check which groups and time points it covers. If the paper reports several outcomes, inspect the one your sentence names.

Check that the DOI, title, authors, and year identify the correct version. Crossref’s metadata search can help with that identity check. See how to verify a citation for the full reference workflow.

Leave a note your coauthor can use

Save one note for each important claim: draft sentence · paper and DOI · exact result · where to find it · limit on interpretation. For the example above, write “Experiment 1, Figure 1; initial recall testing led to better delayed recall, while restudy did better at five minutes; study measured passage recall.” That gives a coauthor enough to check the sentence without rereading the entire paper.

If all the papers you find support a narrower sentence, revise the sentence. If a central claim needs broader evidence, look for studies with the missing outcome or population. Use the source-finding guide to look for candidates and apply the same checks to each one.

AI Source Finder

Compare a draft claim with a study’s task, comparison group, and follow-up.

Open AI Source Finder